Need a simple and quick cookie recipe? These Angel Nutter Butter Cookies are super cute, easy to make, and perfect for the holiday season.
I cannot even tell you how easy this recipe for Angel Nutter Butter Cookies is. It’s the perfect holiday cookie if you ask me. No need to heat the oven or chill any dough. Easy for the kids to decorate on their own, with very little supervision (melting the chocolate should be done with an adult). I even think it’s easier than the Christmas Grinch Bark that I make.
If you’re needing to bring cookies to any kind of Christmas party or to make for your child’s class, this is the recipe for you.
Did I mention, it’s a no-bake recipe?
Table of Contents
- Christmas Sweets Week
- Angel Nutter Butter Cookies
- What are Nutter Butter Cookies?
- Ingredients
- How to Make Angel Nutter Butter Cookies
- Tips, Tricks, and FAQs
Christmas Sweets Week
This wasn’t my planned post for today, as I had life happen this week with car issues and doctor appointments. But I knew these Nutter Butter Angels needed to be shared for #ChristmasSweetsWeek. For this year’s event, I’m joining 11 other fabulous bloggers to satisfy your sweet tooth cravings this holiday season will over 30 sweet treats. You’ll find giftable recipes, breakfast recipes, and delicious dessert recipes. Make sure to follow the hashtag on social media to see our sweet treats.
Angel Nutter Butter Cookies
There’s something about peanut butter and chocolate…any kind of chocolate that is the perfect combination of flavors to satisfy my craving for both. This recipe for Angel Nutter Butter Cookies has both and more.
If you need a cute and unique cookie this holiday season, make these adorable angel cookies. Taking store-bought cookies to the next level will be the talk of your party or event. These would be great to serve while playing this great Christmas party game.
What I love about the cookies is that the kids love to be so creative with decorating their angels. Each one can be so different and they’re all simply adorable.
What are Nutter Butter Cookies?
Nutter Butter Cookies are delicious American peanut butter sandwich cookies made by Nabisco. The unique peanut shape is perfect to use in making these Nutter Butter Angel Cookies. The cookies have been enjoyed by billions for over 50 years.
Ingredients
- 12 Nutter Butter cookies
- 24 pretzel twists (2 for each cookie)
- 12 pineapple-flavored Lifesaver candies (1 for each cupcake)
- White candy melts or vanilla-flavored almond bark
- Chocolate candy melts or chocolate-flavored almond bark
You will also need:
- Toothpick
How to Make Angel Nutter Butter Cookies
Step 1
Line a baking sheet with wax paper.
Step 2
Melt white candy according to package directions making sure not to overheat. If the candy gets too hot, it will seize. If desired, add 1 teaspoon of vegetable shortening or coconut oil to make the melted candy pourable.
Step 3
Dip the pretzel twists in melted candy, allowing the excess to drip back into the bowl. Place the pretzels on waxed paper until dry. Rearrange the pretzels into pairs for wings.
Step 4
Dip Nutter Butter cookies in the melted candy, allowing excess to drip back into the bowl. Place the cookie on the pretzel wings and immediately add the Lifesaver candy as a halo. Allow the cookie to dry completely before continuing with step 5.
Step 5
Melt chocolate candy according to package directions making sure not to overheat. If the candy gets too hot, it will seize. If desired, add 1 teaspoon of vegetable shortening or coconut oil to make the melted candy pourable.
Step 6
Using a toothpick dipped into the melted chocolate, draw two half circles on the uncoated portion of each cookie to be the eyes and a larger dot as the mouth. Allow the cookies to dry completely.
Tips, Tricks, and FAQs
- I used Pineapple Lifesavers for the angels’ halo but feel free to use another color.
- I prefer to use these candy melts, but melting white chocolate chips and semi-sweet chocolate chips can be used.
- Small pretzel twists work best for the wings.
- Get creative and make your angels different colors by adding a couple of drops of food-safe color gel to the white chocolate.
- Refrigerate the cookies to help speed up the drying of the chocolate.
Need more Cookie Recipes? Check out these 30+ Christmas Cookies that are just absolute best!
Angel Nutter Butter Cookies
Ingredients
- 12 Nutter Butter Cookies
- 23 small pretzel twists (2 for each cookie)
- 12 pineapple flavored Lifesaver candies
- White candy melts or vanilla flavored almond bark
- Chocolate candy melts or chocolate flavored almond bark
- toothpick
Instructions
- Line a baking sheet with waxed paper.
- Melt white candy according to package directions making sure not to overheat. If the candy gets too hot, it will seize. If desired, add 1 teaspoon of vegetable shortening or coconut oil to make the melted candy pourable.
- Dip the pretzel twists in melted candy, allowing the excess to drip back into the bowl. Place the pretzels on waxed paper until dry. Rearrange the pretzels into pairs for wings.
- Dip Nutter Butter cookies in the melted candy, allowing excess to drip back into the bowl. Place the cookie on the pretzel wings and immediately add the Lifesaver candy as a halo. Allow the cookie to dry completely before continuing with step 5.
- Melt chocolate candy according to package directions making sure not to overheat. If the candy gets too hot, it will seize. If desired, add 1 teaspoon of vegetable shortening or coconut oil to make the melted candy pourable.
Notes
- I used Pineapple Lifesavers for the angels’ halo but feel free to use another color.
- I prefer to use these candy melts, but melting white chocolate chips and semi-sweet chocolate chips can be used.
- Small pretzel twists work best for the wings.
- Get creative and make your angels different colors by adding a couple of drops of food-safe color gel to the white chocolate.
- Refrigerate the cookies to help speed up the drying of the chocolate.
Friday’s Recipes
- Angel Nutter Butter Cookies from Blogghetti
- Eggnog Pancakes from A Little Fish in the Kitchen
- German Chocolate Pie from A Day in the Life on the Farm
- Peppermint Swirls from Magical Ingredients
- Steamed Pudding Cupcakes from A Kitchen Hoor’s Adventures
Stay connected for the latest recipes
Connect with Blogghetti! Be sure to follow me on my social media, so you never miss a post!
Facebook | Twitter | Pinterest | Instagram
If you try a recipe, please use the hashtag #Blogghetti on INSTAGRAM for a chance to be featured!
Enjoy!
These are so stinking cute! I love the Lifesaver as the halo. This is one the kids could help with!
Thanks for this beautiful recipe.
You’re welcome!
These are adorable!! I plan to make them over Christmas break with my nieces and nephews!
That’s awesome! Perfect edible DIY for kids to make
These look cute and a great idea to make! Kids would love these and these would be great in a cookie tray too.
These angel nutter butter cookies just look adorable! I had to give these a try since I knew my kids would love the look (and as it turns out, the taste!), so I made them the other day. My children and I were not disappointed.
So glad you enjoyed them! SUch a cute recipe.